Big Publisher or Small Publisher: Who's the Better Employer?
Reed's Rx: Convert Pricey Print Medical Journals to Free Ones Online

Lessons Learned from iRate Customers

Iphone3Anyone buying a first generation gadget knows they'll see the price drop in the not-too-distant future.  It happens with everything and it's the price of being an early adopter.  But how early is too early when it comes to vendors reducing prices?  Apple is obviously dealing with this issue right now and it's fascinating to watch the story develop.  Isn't it interesting how iPhone early adopters are up in arms over a $200 drop, but when Apple offers to make up half of that, the anger goes down dramatically?  (And it's being done via a store credit, not a cash refund.)  Does that mean it's OK to hose customers out of $100 but not $200?  Apple seems to be testing and measuring the various pressure points.

More importantly, what should ebook device vendors learn from this?  First of all, Apple always seems to deliver products with feature sets that totally blow away the competition.  It's what could be called a "revolution, not evolution" approach.  Even those of us who aren't Apple fans marvel when Steve Jobs announces the next big thing; it's guaranteed to be full of surprises and why-hasn't-this-feature-always-existed(?!) moments.

When have you felt this way about an ebook device?  Did anyone sense a revolution when Sony released their Reader?  I didn't, and based on the rumors that have been leaked about Amazon's upcoming device, I'm not seeing a revolution on that front either.  (For the record, I'm going solely by what's in that article...I have no info or access to any unreleased ebook devices from anyone.)

What should an ebook vendor do to change the playing field?  First of all, can we please get beyond a monochrome display?!  I'm pretty sure nobody buys monochrome laptops anymore, so can we please move on to full color ebook devices?

Will a full color display drive up the unit price?  Absolutely, and although I've been outspoken in the past about needing to reduce these prices to give them mass market appeal, I'm rethinking that opinion based on the iPhone experience.  Add full color and totally over-deliver on the feature set.  Give customers so much functionality that they're willing to wait in line for it.  And as I said earlier about the iPhone, I think Apple should have gone with an even higher price initially; yes, I tend to believe they should have waited longer than 2 months to reduce the price, but Apple loyalists would have paid another $100 or more at launch.

Go ahead and make your ebook device so darned feature rich that it's irresistible.  Create something that early adopters will jump all over, even if it is pricey at the start.  Then, figure out scaling and component vendor options that allow you to reduce the price down the road.  Even if you need to lose money on every unit sold, use the razor blade and game console model: figure that you'll make your money by selling access to more content.  Notice I said "content", not just books; make sure this device has all the connectivity features to let customers download the latest newspapers, magazines, etc., at home or in the airport.

Be bold.  Come up with something I want to spend $700 or $800 on.


Cecil Vortex

On the flip side, I've spent the last few weeks going "treo? blackberry? treo? blackberry?" I was starting to lean toward ye olde blackberry. Then they dropped the price on the 8 gig iphone and I picked mine up this morning....

In my informal and unscientific poll of iphone folks I know, the consensus appears to be that paying $100 to be the first on the block was worth it. I give Apple points for a wise and swift reversal on the refund question....



It's not the features, though, that makes people love things -- lots of fancy tech gadgets have TONS of features, more than the iPhone. What makes people love things is ease of use. When an ebook is both better AND easier to use than a paper book, that's when we'll see adoption of it.

Michael A. Banks

When people ask me for advice on buying a computer or any other gadget, the first thing I say is, "After you buy one, stop shopping."

Brad V.

In the spring 2007 I splurged and bought the Sony eReader. Personally, I love the e-ink technology, but it doesn't lend itself to doing much more than reading ebooks (no color). While it's capable of holding MP3 files and even has a headphone jack, it has less than 1G of storage, so one can quickly fill up their ebook reader with songs.

For me, ease of use is probably the most important feature of any gadget. I don't want a long learning curve - I want to be up and using my new device as quickly as possible. After ease of use, having a long battery life is also important. Nothing bugs me more than having to recharge the battery every day. But that's just my humble opinion!

Here's a follow-up review I wrote for my Sony eReader:
(sorry, I hope you don't mind the self-promotion of my blog)

Norm Potter

Why not sell eBooks on iTunes? After all they are just digital files. And the new iPhone and IPod Touch are just portable Internet devices.

Kelly Monaghan

Not an Apple fan!!???

And you call yourself a media person. LOL

Norm Potter


The iPhone IS an eBook reader. Just flip it sideways and read a book on the Web.

Norm Potter

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)