Welcoming Ellen to the Blogosphere
The Publishing Careers Blog

The Echoing Green, by Joshua Prager

Echoing_green_2As a loyal baseball fan I'm quite familiar with Bobby Thomsom and his "shot heard round the world" in the 1951 playoff with the Brooklyn Dodgers.  Knowing some of the facts surrounding that big home run and feeling like you've actually just relived it are two completely different things.  Having read Johsua Prager's The Echoing Green I feel like I not only sat in the stands that October afternoon, but I've also become close acquaintances with Thomson and the Dodger on the mound that day, Ralph Branca.

I'm truly amazed at the level of detail Prager provides in this book.  He meticulously describes Thomson and Branca's pro careers and how they crossed paths many times before that fateful day.  Of course, the big story behind this one is the spying and sign-stealing work done by the Giants from their clubhouse perch in center field. If you've heard anything about this part of the story you won't be surprised by what you read in Prager's book; but what you will read is first-hand accounts from many of the Giants on the roster that year, including Thomson himself.

How can an almost 500-page book about one swing of the bat be so entertaining and interesting?  Well, first of all, there's really only about 350 pages of reading material here.  That's not to say the remaining 150 pages are worthless; they're mostly reference material and notes to support all the facts presented throughout the book.  Those sections are tucked away in back and there if you need them.

Prager is clearly a gifted and engaging writer.  He almost makes you feel like you could take a deep breath and smell the concessions stands from almost 60 years ago.  He also does a fantastic job describing the ups and downs of Branca and how he managed to keep his cool (for the most part) over the years, despite the rumblings of Giant cheaters.

Hmmm...Giant cheaters...now that I'm a fan of Prager, I wonder if he'd consider writing another well-researched book on the subject of our modern day Giant cheater...



As a first-time visitor (I got here via LibraryThing's blog) I hate to be querulous, but not to the point of keeping my silence.

On the recommendation of a baseball blog I read I got the book from the library, but I just couldn't read it (and it's not solely because I'm a lifelong Dodgers fan), mostly because of things like this:

...the author has really annoying (not to say wrong) habits of sentence structure.

Example: Writing about Brown v. Board of Education, he says

"The parents wished for their twenty children entrance to a nonsegregated elementary school."

Writing about baseball at Norfolk Naval Base during the war, he says

"Norfolk earmarked annually an incredible $100,000 for its baseball team."

I don't know about you, but those sentences just grate on my ears and in my eyes.

So if you can get past that, I'm sure it's a wonderful book.

Joe Wikert

I think it's safe to say that this book doesn't have the same writing style you'd find with most sports books. I tend to believe that's a good thing though. Prager's style is very conversational and he inserts a lot of side stories throughout the book. Yes, that makes it longer than it could have been had he just stuck with the raw facts. But, again, I found that one of the more enjoyable aspects of the book.


I may try it again, but it almost reads as though it had been translated from German, with the adverbs and prepositional clauses in places I'm just not used to finding them.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)